Discussion about this post

User's avatar
James Smoliga, DVM, PhD's avatar

Interesting study — and I’m a huge fan of getting more sleep, given its many benefits.

That said, a few observations stood out to me:

The intervention was more than “just” extra sleep. Participants got sleep-hygiene counseling that included steps like avoiding caffeine late in the day and exercising earlier. Those changes could influence eating behavior independent of sleep itself — for example, cutting an evening coffee (and the cookie with it) or a post-exercise snack might reduce calories without the extra hour in bed. It raises the question: in a short trial, would similar habit changes have the same effect?

Mechanisms weren’t directly measured. The discussion of hormones like ghrelin and leptin is based on prior literature, but this trial didn’t collect those data.

Insulin sensitivity was originally the top primary outcome in the pre-registered protocol (NCT02253368) and was described in the consent form, along with beta cell function. These were not reported in the paper. The authors don’t explain why, and it would be helpful to understand whether the results were null, not collected, or otherwise unavailable.

The results are specific to this group. Everyone studied was overweight and habitually sleep-deprived at baseline. We don’t know if the same effect would occur in people already getting enough sleep — though the authors note this themselves.

Screen-time trade-off. Participants in the sleep extension group more often reported they “could not watch TV or use the internet as much as they wanted.” That’s not necessarily bad — less screen time can be beneficial — but it raises questions about sustainability in our screen-saturated world.

Well-being gains. Those in the sleep extension group reported notable improvements in mood, energy levels, and ability to work at their best — a major positive.

Because of these factors, it’s hard to say with certainty that extra sleep alone caused the calorie reduction, and I would have liked to see the insulin sensitivity data reported (and find it concerning that it wasn't; it feels like selective reporting).

Still, an approach that helps people sleep more, eat less, and feel better is promising.

Kristie Marble's avatar

This is great evidence. Now what do you do if you’re trying to get all that sleep but your brain wakes up at 3am and despite trying all the tricks-meditation, relaxing the body muscles head to toes, white noise, even exercised for 30min+ that day-and still can’t sleep, giving up at 7am…. What does a person do then?

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?